Alright, first of all let me just say that I know there are six thousand other blog entries out there from the past 3 days on how awesome Coachella was this year. This is in no way a formal evaluation of all the bands who performed, or even just the bands I saw - it’s more a brief list and description of what I saw so I don’t forget and can compare it to future years/shows/etc. Somehow in my intoxicated/sun drunk dancefest vacation, I managed to not only write down every band I caught but also grade them (A-F) in my own little grading system. I think I was quite generous with the grading because I wanted to convince myself that if a band was good enough to make it to Coachella and I had gone out of my way to see them, they couldn’t be bad or that would mean I have bad taste. That said, here are my unimportant, unprofessional and probably a little arrogant breakdowns of who I saw at Coachella 2008:
Friday 4/25
Battles - I would give them a “meh” live, at least compared to what I was expecting. They were melodic but boring - no spark in the performance, and get a B- from me (and my friend Matt, who, incidentally, said “I’d give them a B minus” and sparked my grading system from the beginning).
Black Kids - I gave them an A- with what I thought was potential for a better live performance, maybe if I saw them perform for a full 2 hours as a headliner instead of the mini 40 minute teases at Coachella. They were fun and interacted with the crowd, but I don’t remember much of the actual show (then again, it was the first show I saw on the first day).
Jens Lekman - It was a very upbeat performance - the keyboard was “great and happy sounding” according to my notes, and the violin and xylophone were keeping it real, or at least true to what I thought the artist wanted the music to sound like. Jens scored an A from me.
The Breeders - I initially gave them a B for boring, but the show got better as they went on. There were cute female vocals but the sound wasn’t too original or exciting. Of course they played Cannonball and it was flawless. I bumped them up to an A- by the end - I’m not sure how I was so won over but I was.
Vampire Weekend - They were decent, but I was hoping for more since everyone says they put on a killer show. They were Bish…much better live than on an album. I didn’t much care for their album and I wasn’t blown away at Coachella - maybe they just aren’t the band for me.
Tegan & Sara - These girls were what really started the Coachella party for me. You know how they have such strong vocals on their albums and the instruments just sort of back them up? Well they don’t disappoint live - perfectly on key and every song is really vocally moving, if that makes sense. On top of it all, they know what the crowd wants. They said “we’re gonna play some oldies now if that’s okay with you guys…” and rocked it. A+
Goldfrapp - Straight off the bat she gets an A, but it’s exactly what you’d expect - like when you have really good speakers and blast Goldfrapp to sort of drown out everything and eat your ear drums while dancing? That’s how this show was live. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed the hell out of it, but it still felt like a guilty pleasure.
Aphex Twin - Mind blowingly great performance. Dude. I hate listening to their albums - but I’m that way with a lot of electronicish music: I’d prefer to hear it live any day of the week and just not put it on my iPod. Anyway, they won me over and seriously rocked the stage, not to mention the fact that they were in the cool tent with all the lasers and balloons and trippy visuals on the screens. A+
Fatboy Slim - Okay, rather irritating set. It just sounded like regular old house to me, except he kept building up the music and stopping every fucking 30 seconds to let his ego be massaged. B- and I don’t care if you’re classic/a legend/whatever you want to call him. Get the hell over yourself and put on a show people can actually dance to - I would have rather wound down to Jack Johnson so I could fall asleep easier.
Saturday 4/26
Man Man - I’ve already been fortunate enough to catch them 3 times in Tucson by complete coincidence, and they rocked all 3 times. That said, I was ready to skip them and go see someone else, but we got there early and I hadn’t heard any of the other bands (aside from Minus The Bear) and we wanted to start the day off with a bang - so we saw Man Man for a 4th time. (I’ve already been sorely disappointed by Minus The Bear live once - no desire to watch them again.) They were entertaining and energetic as usual, and put on a fantastic show. Total A.
120 Days - Okay, so we didn’t actually see them or even know who they were, but we walked by their tent and the bass started eating my spinal cord. Definitely need to remember to go see them the next time they’re in town.
Cold War Kids - If you like their album, you’ll like them live, but I can’t say I’m a huge fan. They weren’t bad, but they didn’t have much of a presence - they just played their songs. B or maybe a B+
Stephen Malkmus & The Jicks - They had an awesome live energy, and totally get an A for their performance, but all that struck me was how LOUD the show was even with toilet paper stuffed in my ears. I had to move back from the stage and it kind of distracted me from enjoying the set.
Death Cab For Cutie - I’m a fan - not a big fan but think they’re alright and was totally not expecting them to be that great. I was wrong. I thought they’d have much more of a mainstream blah performance like the Cold War Kids and they didn’t at all - they rocked it live. I wanted to blame it on the awesomeness of the stage, but their set was full of sound and they really had a happy, fun attitude that just misted over the whole audience. Definite A. They would have had to interact more with the crowd or bust out something more original for an A+ in my book.
Islands - I have to start off saying that I really love the Islands and was quite looking forward to this show. When we got there though, most of the set was really slow and I was in a bob around dancey happy Islands music mood which wasn’t fulfilled. It was a great performance, but it wasn’t what I was expecting. My fault or theirs, I’m not sure. A-
Portishead - Even though you expect the performance to be amazing, it still fucking BLOWS YOUR MIND. Portishead rules. Really, I could just leave it at that with an A+ but holy crap did they rock my night! Playing the guitar with a needlenose pliers?? Beth Gibbons having to sit the fuck down during Wandering Star because she sings so fing intensely? Yeah. Their live performances live up to everything you hear. You MUST see Portishead if you ever get the chance. Go - now! Search the internet for tickets at a venue near you!
Prince - The Legend, The Man in Purple, The Artist Formerly Known As The Artist Formerly Known As PRINCE. What can I say? The 5′2 legend can seriously command the attention of a massive audience. All eyes are on him and you wish you were his friend. Yeah, the 80’s are over but you kind of wish they weren’t when listening to a parade of Prince. I think if I had as much coke as all the people on stage (Sheila E, Morris Day), I too could be transported to the 80’s. It was a killer performance with a bunch of oldies and even a cover of Radiohead’s Creep and I think a Beatles song too - I can’t remember. Anyway, A+ to my friend from Minneapolis.
Sunday 4/27
I’m From Barcelona - I had no idea until 5 minutes before the show when Logan told me this is actually a 21 person band…I just thought A LOT of people were helping set up the stage. Let me just say that with I’m From Barcelona, the more people, the more energy and sound. This show absolutely ruled - I think it may have been my surprise favorite. I was stoked to see them to begin with, but the huge band got me with the crowd interaction and admitted “confetti addiction” by the lead singer. A++! Is that a possible grade? Fuck you, it’s my grading system and they get an A++ I’d like to see the Go Team muster up more energy on stage than these guys!
Stars - They were a fun indie band - okay performance that left me with a rather meh attitude which, according to my Battles grade, means B-. They did a cover of the Of Montreal song Live Through This and Of Montreal is one of my favorite bands right now, so that was cool.
Gogol Bordello - Holy Bob. Now this is a perfect example of everything I love in a live show! Gogol Bordello is fun to listen to and dance around in your underwear at home, but there’s something about the headband and gypsy/pirate purple and black striped stretchy capris that just make the music! Energetic is a total understatement…rock your balls off sweating from dancing is more like it. High kicks and punches in the summer sun can’t help but get the rest of the audience jumping! A+ easy - I’d see Gogol Bordello any time they come to town.
Metric - Bam bam bam with the great performances in a row! We ran from the Gogol stage to see Metric and were in for another energetic performance. Not only is Emily Haines adorable when she talks to the crowd, she also wears the cutest outfits on stage to match her mood. She was rocking a shiny blue halter minishorts one piece thing and like Mr. Striped Pants from the show before, she was doing high kicks. This show was too fun, too cute and seriously rocked. A+
Sia - Sia was an incredible one woman show. Even though I know in my head there were people playing instruments behind her, she stood out so much I couldn’t see them at all. Her voice is amazingly beautiful and haunting live - great to trip out and sway along to. I cried when she closed with Breathe Me. Seriously. I mean I totally blame Six Feet Under for having the best ending for any tv series EVER, but she was incredibly moving. It really was an amazing performance. A.
Chromeo - At this point, there was nothing left to do but dance off all the beer and weepy emotions evoked from Sia, and that’s exactly what we did. Chromeo isn’t the best music I’ve ever heard, but it was performed well and got my booty shakin’. B+
Roger Waters - Only caught a 10 or 15 minutes of this show on our night wanderings - exactly what you’d expect a Pink Floyd tribute to sound like. It was good, mellow and trippy, but I just wanted to get to the Justice tent and DANCE.
Justice - …and dance we did. Or continued to do, I should say. Justice is loud, intense sort of Daft Punk like dance music. That kind of says it all. It was a great show. A.